Skip to content

Guides · · 3 min read

Marketing agency audit: 12 questions to find out if you're paying for anything

Marketing agency audit guide: how to audit your media agency's value with data and check whether your agency or digital suppliers return what they cost: accounts, tracking, website, contracts and real cost per customer.

Many companies pay an agency or several digital suppliers every month without knowing for sure what they get in return. Reports talk about impressions, clicks and “reach”, but nobody answers the question that matters: how much does each customer from this channel cost me?

These 12 questions help you audit it yourself. You don’t need to be technical: just ask for access and look carefully.

Start with your website. The free audit checks tracking, cookies, SEO and conversion in 30 seconds.

Run the free audit →

Block 1: ownership and access

1. Are the accounts in your name? Google Ads, Analytics, Search Console, Tag Manager, Meta Business and the domain should belong to your company. The agency should have access, not ownership. If you leave, you take everything.

2. Do you have admin access to everything? If you have to ask for your own numbers, there’s a transparency problem.

3. Who has access to your website, and with what permissions? Old users with admin rights are a security risk almost nobody reviews.

Block 2: tracking

4. Are real enquiries tracked? Forms, calls and WhatsApp should be recorded as conversions. If your campaigns optimise for “page views”, they’re optimising for something you don’t care about. And check that tracking respects cookie consent — see our Consent Mode v2 guide.

5. Do the numbers match? Compare the enquiries you see in your inbox or CRM with what the ad platform reports. Big gaps mean broken tracking or inflated conversions.

6. Is bot traffic filtered out? Some sources generate visits with no value at all. If nobody spots them, reports show growth that doesn’t exist.

Block 3: campaigns

7. What does each enquiry cost, by campaign? You should see the cost per enquiry for every campaign and compare it month by month. A campaign that spends a lot and doesn’t convert needs an explanation and a plan.

8. Is something tested every month? New ads, keywords, landing pages. An account that hasn’t changed in months isn’t being managed.

Block 4: website and content

9. Is your website up to date and fast? Outdated plugins, old versions and slow load times cost money in advertising and rankings. Our 20-point website checklist covers what to look at.

10. Is useful content published regularly? Articles, case studies, news — and, increasingly, content prepared so AI assistants know you.

Block 5: contract and results

11. What exactly does your fee include? Compare the list of services in the contract with what was actually done in the last three months. Ask for the detail.

12. Do you get a report anyone can understand? A good report says what was done, what business result it had and what happens next month — with invoices included.

How to audit your media or marketing agency’s value

Activity reports don’t tell you whether an agency is worth what it costs. Three numbers do:

Metric How to calculate it What to look for
Cost per enquiry (Agency fee + ad spend) ÷ enquiries Stable or falling month by month
Cost per customer (Agency fee + ad spend) ÷ new customers Clearly below what a customer is worth to you
Share of enquiries by channel Enquiries per channel ÷ total enquiries Spend goes where enquiries come from

Use your own data — inbox, CRM or invoices — not only the platform’s figures. If you don’t know how much each published price level should include, our guide on how much a digital marketing agency costs gives market ranges and red flags.

How to read the answers

  • 10 to 12 good answers: you have a serious supplier. Look after them.
  • 6 to 9: clear room for improvement. Ask for a concrete plan with dates.
  • Fewer than 6: you’re probably paying for activity, not results.

Rather have us do it?

In Ekualia’s supplier audit we review all of this with read-only access, cross spend and results month by month and hand you a report with priorities and estimated savings. No obligation to hire us afterwards.

Frequently asked questions

How do I audit my marketing agency's value?

Add up what you pay in a month (agency fee plus ad spend) and divide it by the enquiries and the new customers that month. Compare that cost per customer with what a customer is worth to you, and track it for at least three months. If the agency can't give you those numbers, that is the first finding.

What is a marketing agency audit?

A review of your accounts, tracking, campaigns, website and contract to check whether the money you pay returns enquiries and sales. It can be done by you, with the 12 questions in this guide, or by an independent supplier with read-only access.

How often should I audit my agency?

Look at cost per enquiry every month and do a full review once or twice a year, or whenever results drop or the contract is up for renewal.

Will my agency know I'm auditing them?

If you use your own admin access, you only need to look at data that is already yours. Asking for access you should already have is part of the audit.

  • audit
  • marketing agency
  • Google Ads
  • analytics
  • suppliers

How does your website score?

Audit it free in 30 seconds: over 20 business and technical checks, and what to fix first.